1205 Elm Street

Unknown

Listing courtesy of Steel Valley Homes, 330-406-4663 john@steelvalleyhomes.com

Reduced for quick sale! Historic Youngstown Stone Church For Sale! This Striking Building sits on 2 parcels of land and features ornate exterior
and interior architecture. Former “Richard Brown United Methodist Church”. 4400 SF. Church Built in 1905. Charles
Owsley, Architect. Main entrance features tiled entry way into large parlor room. Front staircase leads to large room with
fireplace with adjacent half bath. Large worship area seats 130+. Pews included. Back staircase leads to 2 upstairs rooms.
Spacious basement has marble fireplace, large seating area, commercial kitchen with island. Commercial stove and
ventilation included. 2 Public restrooms in basement. Ample parking. Short walking distance to YSU, and is situated
directly across from Wick Park. New (3) Heat Pumps (Heat, AC or fan) , updated 200 amp electrical service, shingled roof
estimated to be less than 10 years old. Flat roofs were serviced by Boak & Sons. Zoned as MU-I Mixed Use institutional.
Please view virtual tour before requesting a showing. Please contact agent for more information, virtual tour and
showings.

© 2026 MLS Now (MLSN). All rights reserved. The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange Program of MLSN. Real estate listings held by IDX Brokerage firms other than Steel Valley Homes are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo or the Internet Data Exchange thumbnail logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing Brokers. Information provided is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Listing courtesy of Steel Valley Homes. Data last updated: Wednesday, February 11th, 2026 at 01:36:53 PM.
Data services provided by IDX Broker
MLS Logo

Price:$250,000
Address:1205 Elm Street
City:Youngstown
County:Mahoning
State:Ohio
MLS:5131186
Acres:0.517
Lot Square Feet:0.517 acres
coolingYN:yes
heatingYN:yes
basementYN:yes
currentUse:Mixed Use, Place of Worship
directions:5th Avenue to East on Park then North on Elm. Church is on the right.
permission:IDX
possession:Negotiable
postalCity:YOUNGSTOWN
lotSizeArea:0.517
businessType:Church, Commercial
listingTerms:Cash, Conventional
lotSizeUnits:Acres
lotSizeSource:Assessor
humanModifiedYN:no
taxAnnualAmount:5185
buildingFeatures:Private Restrooms
specialListingConditions:Standard
propertySubTypeAdditional:Other
Please sign up for a Listing Manager account below to inquire about this listing